GATE 2015 CS (CS1) – Question 9
The probabilities that a student passes in Mathematics, Physics and Chemistry are $m$, $p$, and $c$ respectively. Of these subjects, the student has 75% chance of passing in at least one, a 50% chance of passing in at least two and a 40% chance of passing in exactly two. Following relations are drawn in $m$, $p$, $c$:
(I) $p + m + c = 27/20$
(II) $p + m + c = 13/20$
(III) $(p) \times (m) \times (c) = 1/10$
Practise this question in The GATE Grind →
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: (D) Relations I and III are true.
Explanation
Let Pₖ be the probability of passing exactly k subjects. The data give P₂=0.40, P₃=0.50−0.40=0.10, and P₁=0.75−0.50=0.25.
By linearity of expectation, without any independence assumption,
$$m+p+c=P_1+2P_2+3P_3=0.25+0.80+0.30=1.35=\frac{27}{20}.$$
Thus I follows and II is false. However, P₃ is the joint probability of passing all subjects, not automatically the product mpc.
For a concrete compatible model, assign probability 0.10 to passing all three, 0.40 to Mathematics and Physics only, 0.25 to Chemistry only, and 0.25 to none. All given counts hold, but m=p=0.50,c=0.35, so mpc=0.0875 rather than 0.10.
The supplied answer key marks **D (I and III)**; that grading is retained, but the stated data logically justify only I (option A). Adding independence is not a valid repair: m+p+c=1.35 bounds mpc by (1.35/3)³=0.091125, below the required joint probability 0.10. An independence assumption is therefore unjustified.
More Quantitative Aptitude: Probability, Statistics and Combinatorics questions
- GATE 2016 EE Q9
- GATE 2016 EC Q6
- GATE 2017 CS (CS1) Q5
- GATE 2017 CS (CS1) Q9
- GATE 2017 EC Q9
- GATE 2025 ME Q5
All Quantitative Aptitude: Probability, Statistics and Combinatorics questions →