The GATE Grind

GATE 2021 PH – Question 56

Classical Mechanics · D'Alembert's principle, Euler-Lagrange equation, Hamilton's principle, calculus of variations · 2 marks · Multiple select

The total time derivative of a differentiable function $g(q_i,t)$ is added to a Lagrangian: $$L\prime=L(q_i,\dot q_i,t)+\frac{d}{dt}g(q_i,t).$$ Let $p_i,H$ and $p_i\prime,H\prime$ be the respective generalized momenta and Hamiltonians. Which statements are correct?

  1. $L$ and $L\prime$ give the same Euler–Lagrange equations of motion.
  2. $p_i\prime=p_i+\partial g/\partial q_i$
  3. If $p_i$ is conserved, $p_i\prime$ is necessarily conserved.
  4. $H\prime=H+dg/dt$

Practise this question in The GATE Grind →

Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: (A) $L$ and $L\prime$ give the same Euler–Lagrange equations of motion.; (B) $p_i\prime=p_i+\partial g/\partial q_i$

Explanation

Expand $dg/dt=\sum_i(\partial g/\partial q_i)\dot q_i+\partial g/\partial t$. Its contribution to the action is an endpoint term, so fixed-endpoint variations give the same equations of motion: A. Differentiating with respect to $\dot q_i$ gives $p_i\prime=p_i+\partial g/\partial q_i$: B. This additional derivative can vary in time, so C is not necessary. The Legendre transform gives $H\prime=H-\partial g/\partial t$, evaluated at corresponding momenta, not D.

More D'Alembert's principle, Euler-Lagrange equation, Hamilton's principle, calculus of variations questions

All D'Alembert's principle, Euler-Lagrange equation, Hamilton's principle, calculus of variations questions →